Is Anthony Mackie the MCU's Permanent Captain America?

The persistent rumors of Chris Evans' return as Steve Rogers in the Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU) stem from the cyclical nature of comic book deaths and rebirths. In comics, Steve Rogers' death and subsequent revivals, along with similar storylines for other iconic heroes, have established a pattern of the original always returning. This explains the enduring speculation surrounding Evans' potential comeback.

However, the MCU operates differently. Unlike the comics, the MCU prioritizes a sense of permanence. Deaths tend to be final, as evidenced by the continued absence of characters like Thanos and Tony Stark. This creates higher stakes and a unique narrative structure compared to its source material.

Anthony Mackie's Sam Wilson, having inherited the mantle of Captain America, is presented as the definitive Captain America of the MCU. Mackie himself, while unsure of his character's future, expresses hope for Sam's continued tenure. MCU producers and the director of Captain America: Brave New World reinforce this, explicitly stating that Sam Wilson is Captain America, and his leadership will shape the future of the Avengers.

This commitment to permanence distinguishes the MCU from its comic book counterpart, raising the stakes and emphasizing irreversible consequences. While the possibility of Chris Evans' return remains a topic of fan speculation, the MCU's narrative trajectory strongly suggests that Sam Wilson's role as Captain America is established and enduring. The MCU's creators aim for lasting change, and Sam Wilson's Captain America is a testament to that.

Who has been the best Captain America?

Steve RogersJames "Bucky" BarnesSam WilsonIsaiah BradleyJohn WalkerClint BartonSomeone even more obscure (show off your comic knowledge in the comments!)AnswerSee Results